Fiebing’s Leather Dye vs. Pro Dye: Which is Better?

Fiebing’s Leather Dye vs. Pro Dye: Which is Better?

When it comes to dyeing leather, you’ll want the best product for the job. The debate over Fiebing’s Leather Dye vs. Pro Dye has been going on for decades, and now it’s time to settle the score: which is better? In this article, we’ll cover everything you need to know about these two products—including key differences and tips on how to use them most effectively. So let’s dive right in and find out which is the better option!

What Is Fiebing’s Leather Dye?

Fiebing’s leather dye is a high-quality, water-based product that provides excellent coverage. It has been around for over a century and remains one of the most popular choices among professional leatherworkers. This dye penetrates deeply into the leather, providing an even color that won’t fade or rub off. It’s available in a range of colors to match any project. [1]

What Is Pro Dye?

Pro Dye is a synthetic, water-based dye that provides excellent coverage and vibrant colors. It’s easy to apply and can be used in a range of applications including furniture, auto interiors, shoes, wallets, and more. The advantages of using Pro Dye include fast drying time (usually just a few minutes), as well as long-lasting results that won’t fade or rub off.

Another unique benefit of Pro Dye is its non-flammable and non-hazardous nature, which makes it much more safe to use in any home environment. [1]

What Is Pro Dye?

Clearing up Myths & Misconceptions

The debate surrounding Fiebing’s Leather Dye vs. Pro Dye has been ongoing for years, with each side arguing the merits of their preferred choice. Unfortunately, much of this discussion is driven by myths and misconceptions that often don’t give a full picture of which option would be better in any given situation.

To help clear up some of the confusion, let’s take a look at what each product offers and how they differ.

Fiebing’s Leather Dye is an all-natural dye that has been formulated to be fast-drying and long lasting. It can be used on both light and dark leathers, but it may not work as well on some of the softer, more delicate leathers. Fiebing’s Leather Dye is also quite affordable and easy to use, making it a great choice for those on a budget or short on time.

Pro Dye, on the other hand, is specifically designed for use with synthetic leathers and is formulated to be highly fade-resistant. It works well on light and dark leathers, but it may not be as effective on softer leathers. It also tends to cost more than Fiebing’s Leather Dye and can be more difficult to use. [1]

When You Might Use Fiebing’s Leather Dye?

Fiebing’s leather dye is a great option for those who need to dye their leather quickly and conveniently. It has been around since 1895 and has proven to be a reliable product for many leatherworking applications. Fiebing’s Leather Dye is easy to apply, comes in an array of colors, and dries quickly with no need for buffing. It is also very economical when compared to many other leather dyes.

Fiebing’s Leather Dye works well on all types of smooth and lightly textured calfskin, cowhide, goat skin, sheepskin, suede, and vegetable-tanned leathers. The colors are vibrant and long-lasting. [1]

When You Might Use Pro Leather Dye?

When you are looking for a leather dye that is fast drying, Pro Leather Dye is a great choice. It dries in about 5-10 minutes compared to Fiebing’s, which takes over an hour. Additionally, the color you mix won’t fade as quickly as Fiebing’s can and it will resist fading from sunlight better.

If you are looking for a dye that will penetrate deeper into the leather, Pro Leather Dye is also a great choice. It has been designed to penetrate more deeply than Fiebing’s, giving your project an even and lasting color. [1]

When You Might Use Pro Leather Dye?

Fiebing’s Leather Dye Types and Variations

Fiebing’s is a well-known and trusted name in the leather industry. They offer a variety of dyes to suit any project you may have. Whether it’s for furniture, shoes, or leather goods, Fiebing’s has a solution.

The most popular type of dye from Fiebing’s is their leather dye. This dye is specifically designed to deeply penetrate the fibers of the leather, ensuring a long-lasting color. Fiebing’s also offers a wide range of colors and shades, so you can find just the right hue for your project.

In addition to their traditional dyes, Fiebing’s also offers specialized dyes such as a black dye that won’t rub off; silver metallic dyes; and even special colors to match specific shades of leather. [1]

Pro Dye Types and Variations

While Fiebing’s provides excellent quality dyes, Pro Dye is another well-known name in the industry. They offer a wide range of products to choose from, and they specialize in dyes that provide excellent color intensity and vibrancy. Their dyes come in a variety of formulas, making them suitable for different types of leathers.

Pro Dye’s standard mix is its water-based dye, which comes in three shades—dark brown, black, and medium brown—and seven translucent colors. The water-based dye works best on smooth leathers, such as nubuck or full-grain leather.

If you want to dye a rough and absorbent leather, like suede or unfinished/tumbled grain, Pro Dye also offers an oil-based formula. Like the water-based mix, the oil-based dye comes in three shades—black, medium brown, and dark brown—and seven translucent colors.

Pro Dye’s alcohol-based formula is a suitable option if you want to dye a smooth leather with the convenience of a spray bottle applicator. The alcohol-based dye comes in four colors and can be used on smooth leathers such as nubuck. [1]

Fiebing’s Leather Dye Characteristics

When it comes to leather dye, Fiebing’s is a popular option. Fiebing’s makes water-based dyes in an array of colors, so you can easily match your project’s desired color. It is easy to apply and works on any type of leather or suede material. The pigments in these dyes are fast drying, and you will see a dramatic improvement in the look of your leather after just one coat.

Another great thing about Fiebing’s is that it won’t crack or peel, making it perfect for long-lasting projects. It also does not contain any harmful chemicals, so you can safely use it around kids and pets without worry. Thanks to its waterproof features, you won’t have to worry about your leather getting ruined by water or other liquids. [1]

Fiebing’s Leather Dye Characteristics

Pro Dye Characteristics

If you’re looking for a reliable and durable solution, Pro Dye is a great choice. It’s specifically designed for shoes and other footwear products, so it works well on these types of materials. This dye provides excellent coverage and resists fading. It’s also water-resistant and provides superior adhesion to leather surfaces, so it won’t easily chip or peel off. Additionally, Pro Dye is available in several colors and shades for added flexibility when choosing a dye that matches your particular needs. [1]

Pro Leather Dye Characteristics

Pro Leather Dye provides excellent coverage that will penetrate deeply into the leather. It is made from a blend of high-quality, fast-drying dyes and conditioners. The colors are vibrant and long lasting, and won’t fade over time. Pro Leather Dye also resists cracking, streaking, fading, and rubbing off when applied properly — making it a great choice for leather goods that will get a lot of wear and tear.

Pro Leather Dye is fast drying, so you don’t have to wait long for the dye to set. It also has an easy-to-use applicator brush, which makes application fast and simple. Once applied, Pro Leather Dye doesn’t need to be sealed afterward; it sets and dries quickly to a beautiful finish. [1]

Fiebing’s Leather Dye Characteristics

Fiebing’s leather dye is well-known for its superior coverage, long lasting color, and ease of use. It comes in more than 40 colors including bright metallics, so you can find the perfect shade for your project. The dye is formulated to penetrate deeply into leather and bond with the proteins within the fibers, which helps create a durable finish that won’t easily wear away or fade. It also dries quickly and can be used on smooth and suede leather, as well as vinyl and other synthetic materials. [1]

Fiebing’s Leather Dye Cons

The biggest con of using Fiebing’s dye is that it only works on certain types of leather. You should always make sure to read the instructions carefully before use and test a small area first to check for compatibility. The other downside is that you cannot mix colors when using this product, so if you want multiple hues on your project, you will have to use a different product.

Additionally, Fiebing’s dye does not have any UV protection, so it is not suitable for items that will be left in the sun. Additionally, there is no moisture protection with this product, so you should take extra care when using it on leather goods that will be exposed to rain or other types of moisture. [1]

Fiebing’s Leather Dye Cons

Pro Leather Dye Cons

Pro Leather Dye is not as easy to apply as Fiebing’s Leather Dye. It requires several coats and must be allowed to dry in between. Additionally, Pro Leather Dye does not have the same range of colors that Fiebing’s offers, so it may be harder to match existing leather colors. Also, since it doesn’t penetrate the leather as deeply, it may not be as long-lasting. So if you’re looking for a quick and easy dye job or an exact color match, Pro Leather Dye is probably not the best option. However, if you’re willing to put in some extra effort and have patience while applying coats of dye, Pro Leather Dye can produce beautiful results. [1]

Fiebing’s Leather Dye Manufacturing Process

Fiebing’s leather dye is made with a special formula that has remained unchanged for over 100 years. The dyes are made using a combination of synthetic and natural ingredients to create the perfect color for every situation. Fiebing’s uses only the highest quality materials in its production process, ensuring each bottle of dye produces consistent results. To ensure they produce a consistent result, Fiebing’s dye is tested for colorfastness and lightfastness before it reaches the customer. [1]

Pro Dye Manufacturing Process

Pro Dye also uses a combination of synthetic and natural ingredients to produce their dyes. Unlike Fiebing’s, Pro Dye does not use any animal products in its production process, making it a more eco-friendly option than Fiebing’s leather dye. Pro Dye also tests its dyes for colorfastness and lightfastness to ensure each bottle produces consistent results. [1]

Alternative Options

Though Fiebing’s Leather Dye and Pro Dye are both popular choices, there are alternative options as well. If you’re looking for a more natural leather dye, consider using vegetable tanning solutions from a craft store. These solutions are all-natural and will give your leather product an even, earthy tone. You can also try using a commercial-grade leather dye or an alcohol-based dye if you need a higher concentration of color.

No matter which type of dye you choose, be sure to read the instructions carefully and wear appropriate protective gear when working with them. When in doubt, always talk to an experienced professional for advice on how to properly care for your leather goods. [1]

Alternative Options

Experienced Tips for Working with Leather Dye

When working with leather dye, it’s important to be aware of the differences between Fiebing’s Leather Dye and Pro Dye. Both are effective ways to color your leather but have different pros and cons. To help you make the right choice, here are some tips from experienced users:

  1. Always use a well-ventilated area when applying dye. This is especially important if you’re using Pro Dye, which has a more pungent smell than Fiebing’s Leather Dye.
  2. Make sure the leather you’re working with is clean and dry before applying any dye. If it isn’t, the color won’t be even or last long.
  3. Use a brush or sponge to apply the dye, and avoid wiping it on with your hands. This will help you achieve an even finish and prevent staining your skin.
  4. Fiebing’s leather dye is waterproof when dry, so it’s ideal for items that will be exposed to rain or water. On the other hand, Pro Dye is not waterproof and can fade over time.
  5. Always read the instructions and safety information on the dye’s packaging before starting your project. This will help you understand how to use the product properly and avoid any accidents or injuries. [1]

Fiebing’s Leather Dye Care and Maintenance

When dealing with leather, it’s important to properly care for the material. Fiebing’s Leather Dye is a great choice because it can be used on a wide variety of leathers without damaging or discoloring them. Here are some tips to keep your leather looking great:

  • Always test the dye first on an inconspicuous area before using it on the entire leather item.
  • Clean and condition the leather regularly to prevent cracking or fading of the dye color.
  • If you are going to store your leather items for an extended period, use a breathable fabric bag lined with acid free paper to protect them from moisture damage and discoloration.
  • Be sure to store your leather items away from direct sunlight to avoid fading or discoloration.
  • Be careful when using any cleaning products on dyed leather, as they may cause discoloration or damage to the surface. [1]

Pro Leather Dye Care and Maintenance

When it comes to leather dye, proper care and maintenance is essential for the best results. Here are some tips to help your leather look like new:

  1. Always wear protective gloves when applying leather dye or cleaning the area around it. This will protect your skin from any potential hazards associated with the chemicals used in the dyes.
  2. Once the dye is applied, use a soft cloth to buff the leather. This removes any excess dye and makes sure that the color is even and consistent.
  3. Regularly condition your leather. Conditioning helps keep the leather hydrated and prevents it from becoming dry or cracked.
  4. Use a waterproof sealant to help protect against water damage. This will also help protect the dye from fading or discoloration over time.
  5. Store leather items away from direct sunlight and other sources of heat when not in use to ensure that they stay looking new for longer. [1]


Which leather dye is best?

The answer depends on the type of leather you’re dyeing, the color you want to achieve, and what kind of finish you’re looking for. Fiebing’s Leather Dye is a good general-purpose leather dye ideal for most soft and smooth finished leathers. It can be used to change colors or darken existing colors.

What are the best natural leather dyes?

For natural leather dyes, you can look for products that contain organic and plant-based ingredients. Fiebing’s Pro Dye is a great option as it contains no harsh chemicals or additives and is made from vegetable extracts. It’s also very easy to apply and achieve a beautiful finish with minimal effort.

What is the best way to dye leather?

The best way to dye leather is with a pre-mixed leather dye, such as Fiebing’s Leather Dye or Pro Dye. If you are using Fiebing’s Leather Dye, it is important to follow the directions on the label carefully and apply even layers of the dye until the desired color is achieved.

Which dye is used in the leather industry?

Fiebing’s Leather Dye is a popular choice in the leather industry due to its ease of use and versatility. It can be used to create any color from black to light brown. Pro Dye is also commonly used, as it produces vibrant colors that are resistant to fading or running.

Is Fiebing’s leather dye water based?

No, Fiebing’s Leather Dye is an oil-based dye. It is formulated with a blend of fats and waxes that penetrate into the leather to create a long-lasting bond. The oil in the dye helps protect the leather from dirt, water, and other elements.

Does leather dye last?

Yes, when applied properly, leather dye can last for years. To ensure your dyed leather lasts as long as possible, it’s important to clean and condition the leather before dyeing. Additionally, be sure to use a quality pre-mixed dye that is specifically designed for use on leather. Fiebing’s Leather Dye and Pro Dye both provide excellent coverage and long-lasting results.

What are the different types of leather dye?

The two most popular types of leather dye are oil-based and water-based dyes. Oil-based dyes, such as Fiebing’s Leather Dye, penetrate into the leather to create a permanent bond that resists fading and wear. Water-based dyes, like Pro Dye, are easier to apply but may not be as resilient or fade-resistant as oil-based dyes.

Useful Video: The Leather Element: Water Based Dye vs. Pro Dye


So, when it comes to choosing between Fiebing’s Leather Dye and Pro Dye, both have their advantages and disadvantages. Ultimately, the decision should be based on your personal preference as well as the specific needs of your project. If you’re looking for a reliable, easy-to-use product that can provide long-lasting results, Fiebing’s Leather Dye is the way to go. However, if you want a product that dries quickly and can provide vibrant colors with just one application, Pro Dye may be the better choice for you. No matter which product you choose, remember to always follow the manufacturer’s instructions for best results! Good luck and happy dyeing!